
Since I just started reading this book, I don't really have enough information to start analyzing the text. However, I have a couple predictions based on what I already have read.
My first prediction is that Clay will learn a lot about the effect he has on other people, and most importantly, learn his effect that he had on Hannah. Since Clay has gotten the cassette tapes, Hannah had him as a reason why she killed herself. Right now, even Clay isn't sure what he did wrong, especially because everybody calls him the nicest kid in town. "What did I do to you, Hannah?" (Asher, 55) is the phrase that keeps coming back to clay as he listens to what Hannah is saying to him.
My second prediction is that Hannah will reveal some secrets about herself and other people she knew during her life. She will tell Clay some surprising information, and it will most likely be hard for Clay to listen to these revealed secrets, and maybe even difficult for him to look at people the same way again. Clay has recieved the tapes from somebody else who sent them, and Clay thinks about what is happening to these other people involved with the tapes, "I can't imagine what it was like for him to mail out these tapes. To know that he was sending his secret into the world." (Asher, 56). This quote shows that Clay knows that it is tough for people to let their secrets be revealed for them.
My last prediction is that Clay will not tell anybody about the cassette tapes that Hannah sent to him. I think that Clay will not show anybody else, fearing that they may learn something about him or that all of the secrets will be revealed to everybody. I can make this prediction based on Clay's thoughts, "As the stories go by, one by one, I find myself relieved when my name isn't mentioned. Followed by a fear of what she hasn't yet said, of what she's going to say, when my turn comes. Because my turn is coming. I know that. and I want it to be over with. What did I do to you, Hannah?" (Asher, 55). This is constantly coming back to Clay, because he doesn't understand what he did wrong, and he is anxious to know what he did to harm Hannah and cause her to do such a horrible thing.
I know that since this book is about suicide, many teenagers can relate to this book. I'm not sure if I can specifically relate to that topic, but I can relate to the way Hannah felt when she was making the tapes. Clay noticed that Hannah's voice was trembling, and that she must have been sad, or felt angry or alone because of what these people did to her. I know I have been sad before, and I'm sure that everybody in their life has encountered a bully who said mean things to them, so not only I can relate to this book, but I feel that most teenagers can.
I am looking forward to reading the book and getting some of my questions answered.
What did Clay do to Hannah? Why did Hannah make the tapes, other than to share secrets? What made Hannah decide to take her own life?
This is an AMAZING blog post! What you predicted and told me about the tapes ave me chills and made me want to run and read the book right now. All the questions you had sparked my curiosity and made me think. I love how you pointed out that every teenager has probably felt the way Hannah is at some point or another...I know I have and I bet everyone else has too. I've had this book on my "to-read" shelf on goodreads for a while and thanks to your blog post I think I've found what I want to read next!
ReplyDeleteThis looks like a great book to read and I have to add it to my to-read list. I like that you said that it may be uncomfortable to read and how you related it to our society today.
ReplyDeleteI really love the way you worded this log post. The post made me want to read the book and put it near the top of my to-read list. One of my favorite things about your post is how you periodically ask yourself questions about the book. I've been looking for a book to read that sounds very interesting, and thanks to you, I've found something so interesting!
ReplyDeleteI liked how you backed up your predictions with evidence from the text and characterized both Clay and Hannah. I liked how you analyzed the text and made solid predictions with reasoning behind them. Mystery books are always suspenseful,and I predict that your book will be as well.
ReplyDeleteGreat post Georgia! I really would love to read this novel now. You did a great job with backing up your predictions with specific evidence from the text. It still seems to sound very sad, so you are going to have to keep me posted on how its going in class! Mystery books are by far my favorite, so I will have to add this to the list!
ReplyDeleteGreat post Georgia! I really would love to read this novel now. You did a great job with backing up your predictions with specific evidence from the text. It still seems to sound very sad, so you are going to have to keep me posted on how its going in class! Mystery books are by far my favorite, so I will have to add this to the list!
ReplyDeleteThis was such a great post! I really liked how you were continuously asking yourself questions, it really makes me curious about why she would do such a terrible thing. I will be definitely reading this book in the future.
ReplyDeleteOoooooo, I've always wanted to read this book but I've never met anybody who read it before.
ReplyDeleteIt's a shame that you believe that lots of teenagers would be able to relate to this book since it's about suicide and its consequences. It's also a shame that it's true.
I'm assuming that Hana killed herself because of bullying since that's a big problem we have in our schools. I wonder if Hana had people that could've saved her if they had noticed the signs. Or if she didn't want to be saved. And she wanted to die so the people would be taught a lesson.
Oh, this is very detailed! I really like your predictions that you made, they made me think of some predictions of what you gave for a quick "set-up" of the book! Hannah seems like the type of character that would hide some really big secret and then tell it at the very end! Maybe this is why Clay continues to listen to the tapes?
ReplyDeleteBut yeah, I think that Clay's going to realize that there's maybe a bigger reason of why Hannah committed suicide and it's going to be explained through the entire book. One things for sure, a lot will be revealed about Hannah and Clay.
I think I will be considering to read this book in the near future, it's getting me really curious and wanting more. :D
Good job Jessica! I can see each prediction in my head and why. As I read each prediction, I see the character and the tension between them and the environment around them. I can also feel the predictions happening from this post.
ReplyDeleteThis is a great post! I started reading this book last year but I lost interest and never finished, however I am hoping to pick it up again soon. Based on where you got your quotes from, I am probably further than you. When I started reading the book, I had a lot of the same predictions you did. I also really like how said that teenagers could relate to Hannah at some point in their life. Thanks for this post, you inspired me to read this again!!
ReplyDeleteI really liked how you started your post with a quote in italics. It grabbed my attention and enhanced the design of your post. Good job incorporating evidence from the text into your predictions, also. That's hard for me to do sometimes. Nice job with this solid post! Definitely made me want to read this again.
ReplyDeleteYou did a great job with your predictions about the book. Hopefully as you continue to read the book, some of your predictions may come true! If so, I think that would be a great blog topic you could use to further explain your predictions and how close they were to reality.
ReplyDelete